Can a Landlord Change Their Mind After Verbal Agreement?

Yes, a landlord can change their mind after a verbal agreement.

Can A Landlord Change Their Mind?

One of the common concerns for tenants and potential renters is whether a landlord can change their mind after making a verbal agreement. Verbal agreements are often made during the rental negotiation process, but it is crucial to understand the validity, enforceability, and exceptions surrounding such agreements.

Understanding The Validity Of Verbal Agreements

Verbal agreements, though not as legally binding as written contracts, can still hold some weight in certain situations. The validity of a verbal agreement may depend on various factors:

  • The applicable state laws: Different jurisdictions have different regulations regarding the enforceability of verbal agreements. It’s essential to understand the specific laws in your state.
  • The nature of the agreement: Verbal agreements can be valid for some types of tenancies, such as month-to-month leases or agreements for rental periods under a certain duration.
  • Proof of agreement: While verbal agreements can be challenging to prove, supporting evidence like witnesses or written correspondence can significantly strengthen your case.

Factors That May Affect The Enforceability Of Verbal Agreements

Even if a verbal agreement seems valid, certain factors can affect its enforceability:

  • Statute of Frauds: Some jurisdictions require certain agreements, including lease agreements, to be in writing to be enforceable. Familiarize yourself with your state’s Statute of Frauds to understand if your verbal agreement may be affected.
  • Contradictory terms: If the terms of the verbal agreement conflict with the terms of any written agreement or lease, it may raise questions about the validity of the verbal agreement.
  • Landlord-tenant laws: Landlord-tenant laws vary by jurisdiction and may include specific provisions requiring written agreements for certain circumstances.

Exceptions To Verbal Agreements

While verbal agreements can hold some weight, there are exceptions where they may not be enforceable:

  • Illegal terms: If the agreed-upon terms violate any laws, the verbal agreement will likely not be enforceable.
  • Complex agreements: In complex rental arrangements involving multiple terms and conditions, written agreements are generally preferred to avoid misunderstandings.
  • Renewal or modification: When renewing a lease or modifying an existing agreement, it is advisable to have the changes documented in writing to prevent any disputes.

While verbal agreements can be legally binding in certain situations, it is always best to have a written lease agreement to protect both parties’ rights and ensure clarity. Having a written agreement provides a sense of security and serves as tangible evidence, which can save you from potential disputes and headaches down the line.

What To Do If A Landlord Changes Their Mind

If a landlord changes their mind after a verbal agreement, tenants can take steps to protect their rights and negotiate a solution. Communicating clearly and documenting the agreement can help mitigate potential issues and ensure a fair resolution.

Communication And Negotiation

One of the first steps to take if a landlord changes their mind after a verbal agreement is to open up effective communication and try negotiation. Approaching the situation with a calm and understanding demeanor can help alleviate tension between both parties. Here are a few steps to consider:

1. Initiate a conversation: Reach out to your landlord and express your concerns about the change of mind. It’s important to clarify the reasons behind their decision and to communicate your own expectations and understanding of the initial agreement.

2. Listen actively: Give your landlord an opportunity to explain their reasons. Maintaining an open mind and actively listening to their perspective can lead to a better understanding of their concerns and potential areas for compromise.

3. Propose alternative solutions: During your conversation, suggest alternatives that could address your landlord’s concerns while still addressing your own needs. This can open up a constructive dialogue and potentially lead to a mutually satisfactory outcome.

4. Put the agreement in writing: If you are able to come to a new agreement with your landlord, it is essential to put the revised terms in writing. This can provide clarity and legal protection for both parties and help avoid any future misunderstandings.

Reviewing Local Laws And Lease Documents

It’s crucial to familiarize yourself with local laws and review the lease documents if your landlord changes their mind after a verbal agreement. Understanding your rights and responsibilities can give you leverage when discussing the situation with your landlord. Consider the following steps:

1. Research local tenant laws: Research the tenant laws in your area to have a clear understanding of your rights as a renter. This knowledge can help guide your conversation with your landlord and ensure that any proposed changes are within the legal boundaries.

2. Review lease documents: Carefully examine the lease agreement you signed with your landlord. Pay close attention to any clauses or provisions related to changes in the terms of the agreement. Having a clear understanding of your rights and obligations outlined in the lease can provide a strong foundation for negotiation.

3. Highlight relevant sections: If you find any sections in the lease agreement that support your initial verbal agreement, make sure to highlight and reference them during your conversation with your landlord. This can help strengthen your position and emphasize the importance of honoring the original agreement.

Seeking Legal Advice

In some cases, seeking legal advice may be necessary if your landlord changes their mind after a verbal agreement. By consulting with a legal professional, you can gain clarity on your legal rights and explore potential legal remedies. Consider the following steps:

1. Find a reputable attorney: Research and find a reputable attorney specializing in landlord-tenant disputes. Look for someone with experience in your local area to ensure they have knowledge of the relevant laws.

2. Explain the situation: Provide your attorney with all the necessary details about the verbal agreement and subsequent change of mind by your landlord. Be honest and transparent to enable your attorney to provide accurate advice.

3. Discuss potential legal actions: With the guidance of your attorney, discuss potential legal actions that can be taken if necessary. This could include filing a lawsuit to enforce the initial agreement or seeking compensation for any damages incurred due to the change of mind.

Remember that each situation is unique, and the steps to take when a landlord changes their mind can vary. Considering these recommendations can help you navigate the situation effectively, protect your rights, and reach a resolution that works for both parties.

Frequently Asked Questions On Can A Landlord Change Their Mind After Verbal Agreement?

Can A Landlord Back Out Of A Verbal Agreement?

Yes, a landlord can back out of a verbal agreement.

Can You Change Your Mind On A Verbal Agreement?

Yes, you can change your mind on a verbal agreement. However, it’s important to communicate your decision to the other party. Verbal agreements hold legal weight, but they can be modified or cancelled through mutual consent.

Will A Verbal Agreement Stand Up In Court?

Verbal agreements may not hold up in court due to lack of evidence. Court prefers written agreements to ensure clarity and avoid disputes. It’s always advisable to have written contracts in place to protect the interests of all parties involved.

Does A Verbal Agreement Mean Anything In Real Estate?

Yes, a verbal agreement can hold legal weight in real estate transactions. However, it is advisable to have written documentation to avoid potential disputes or misunderstandings. An attorney can provide guidance on the enforceability of verbal agreements in your specific situation.


Ultimately, the question of whether a landlord can change their mind after a verbal agreement is a complex one. While verbal agreements may hold weight, legally binding contracts provide more security for both parties involved. It is crucial to always have a written agreement and consult with legal experts to ensure protection and clarity in any rental transaction.

Transparency and open communication between landlords and tenants can help avoid misunderstandings and protect the rights of both parties.

Leave a Comment